UPDATE: Missing teens from Huntley, Crystal Lake found safe

Emilia Rechsteiner, 14, of Huntley and Elizabeth Ernst, 15, of Crystal Lake are seen in a surveillance photo arriving at Ogilvie Transportation Center in Chicago at about 6 p.m. Tuesday, May 20, 2025. They were reported missing.

Police announced Thursday afternoon that two teens who were missing from Huntley and Crystal Lake since Tuesday had been found safe.

“With the help of the FBI and the Chicago Police Department, they were taken into protective custody by the Huntley Police Department,” Huntley authorities said shortly after 4 p.m. “The Crystal Lake Police Department and Metra Police were also instrumental in locating these juveniles. We also thank the public for their assistance in sharing this information."

Police said an investigation into the missing teens still was pending and “no additional information will be released at this time.”

Huntley police had reported Wednesday that Emilia Reichsteiner, 14, of Huntley and Elizabeth Ernst, 15, of Crystal Lake did not return from school Tuesday. On Thursday, police said they believed they had taken a train into Chicago and were possibly with an unidentified male.

Authorities asked for the public’s help in identifying the young man or provide security footage that might offer any leads. Anyone who could identify the male was asked to call the Huntley Police Tip Line at 847-515-5333.

This unidentified male was believed to be in the company of missing juveniles Emilia Rechsteiner, 14, of Huntley and Elizabeth Ernst, 15, of Crystal Lake. They were reported missing Tuesday, May 20, 2025.
Have a Question about this article?