Steve Soucie’s Week 6 playoff projection: Small margins lead to big differences

Fields start to stabilize but lines still shifting

Steve Soucie's Week 6 playoff projections

Multiple games around the state came down to the wire in a crazy Week 6 in IHSA football.

Outcomes turned on a dime in the final minute with teams both succeeding and failing to convert 2-point conversions.

Sometimes those results come between two teams that are ultimately going to make the playoffs regardless of how the game turns out.

Others, however, can have wildly sweeping consequences to teams on both sides of the ledger.

Joliet Catholic scored in the final minute of Friday night’s game with Marist to take the lead and then hung on for the victory when a Marist receiver was tackled inside the 10-yard line on the final play of the game. The Hilltoppers now need just one win to earn playoff eligibility instead of dropping to .500, but that final twist of fate put a big hurt on Marist’s playoff prospects . The Redhawks are now 1-5 and will only see a postseason berth if they run the table and are fortunate enough to be granted a reprieve as a four-win at-large team. That’s a tall order.

In two consecutive weeks the Western Illinois Valley Conference produced a pair of one-point decisions in the middle of its conference packs. Those results could be the difference between a 4-5 record and a 5-4 record for all four of the teams involved.

These really are the manifestation of coin flip games. If some of these teams were to play each other 10 times, each of them would probably win five.

Other games that affected the construction of this week’s projection were Wheaton Warrenville South toppling Wheaton North. The Tigers aren’t assured a spot because of the win but the path got clearer and likely means that this week’s game with Lake Park will decide if and how the DuKane Conference sends another team to the postseason.

Sterling’s win over Geneseo put the Golden Warriors firmly back in the postseason race. But its work isn’t done as it will still need a win over longtime rival Moline or an upset victory over Western Big Six favorite Quincy in the final three weeks of the season.

Two-point conversions also played a factor in how the middle of the pack of the Kishwaukee River/Interstate Eight Blue will sort out. Ottawa stopped a two-point conversion that would have led to a loss, while LaSalle-Peru didn’t get the stop in a similar situation. Both are 3-3 now. They play in Week 7 and each still have to deal with conference front runner Sycamore in one of their other two games. There’s absolutely no doubt that those 2-point conversions will weigh heavily on whether or not, one or none of them get into the dance.

Most of the instability resided right in the middle of the projected field with five changes in each the Class 4A and Class 5A fields. Class 1A and Class 7A were the most stable with only one field change in each classification.

In all, 15 new/returning schools were added into the projection. The source of many of those new teams was a need to add six four-win teams to the field to get to the required 256 qualifiers. Schools with high playoff points and a projected four wins were Glenbrook South, Quincy Notre Dame, Benet, Bolingbrook, Marist and Fieldcrest.

Here is the Week 6 playoff projection for all eight classes. (Included in Class 1A through 6A are north/south divisional maps and below each bracket is more context on what happened in Week 5 that changed the make-up of the brackets):

Class 1A

Class 1A Enrollment Range: Up to 303

Largest 1A teams by enrollment: Arthur, Oakwood, Fieldcrest, Cumberland, Althoff

Smallest 2A teams by enrollment: Bloomington Central Catholic, Momence, Chicago Christian, Tri-Valley, Illini West

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
ArthurWas in 2A

Class 1A North/South Map

Class 2A

Class 2A Enrollment Range: 304.5 to 409.5

Largest 1A teams by enrollment: Arthur, Oakwood, Fieldcrest, Cumberland, Althoff

Smallest 2A teams by enrollment: Bloomington Central Catholic, Momence, Chicago Christian, Tri-Valley, Illini West

Largest 2A teams by enrollment: Wilmington, Nashville, Dwight, Seneca, Marian Central Catholic

New teams in the field:

Team addedReason for addition
ChesterContinues to recover from very difficult nonconference schedule
Hamilton CountyHas tenuous hold on spot in middle of Black Diamond Conference
Quincy Notre DameLikely to finish with 4 wins, but flush with playoff points
WesclinHas two very good chances to snag fifth win

Class 2A North/South Map

Class 3A

Class 3A Enrollment Range: 412 to 553

Largest 2A teams by enrollment: Wilmington, Nashville, Dwight, Seneca, Marian Central Catholic

Smallest 3A teams by enrollment: Carlinville, Crane/Oregon (same enrollment), Fairfield, Sherrard

Largest 3A teams by enrollment: Harrisburg, Phillips, Greenville, Benton, Prairie Central

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
BentonUpset win over Nashville gets them in
PhillipsWas in 4A
HarrisburgWas in 4A

Class 3A North/South Map

Class 4A

Class 4A Enrollment Range: 554.5 to 892

Largest 3A teams by enrollment: Harrisburg, Phillips, Greenville, Benton, Prairie Central

Smallest 4A teams by enrollment: Dyett, Phoenix, Peoria Notre Dame, Kewanee, Richmond-Burton

Largest 4A teams by enrollment: Evergreen Park, Rochelle, Centralia, Morris, St. Laurence

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
RochelleWas in Class 5A
Evergreen ParkWas in Class 5A
CentraliaSouth Seven Conference difficult to figure
Noble/RaunerUnclear how CPL plans to break ties
LincolnJacksonville upset gets them in; could be first bid since 1984

Class 4A North/South Map

Class 5A

Class 5A Enrollment Range: 897.5 to 1363

Largest 4A teams by enrollment: Evergreen Park, Rochelle, Centralia, Morris, St. Laurence

Smallest 5A teams by enrollment: Highland, Corliss, Metamora, Carbondale, Noble/UIC

Largest 5A teams by enrollment: Centennial, Dunlap, Kaneland, Danville, Providence

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
CentennialWas in 6A
DunlaoWas in 6A
OttawaStill a slippery path to a bid, but there is a path
SterlingVictory over Geneseo could end up being huge
TriadMiddle of the pack in Mississippi Valley is muddled

Class 5A North/South Map

Class 6A

Class 6A Enrollment Range: 1374.5 to 1819.95

Largest 5A teams by enrollment: Centennial, Dunlap, Kaneland, Danville, Providence

Smallest 6A teams by enrollment: Simeon, Lemont, Wauconda, Bremen, Lake View

Largest 6A teams by enrollment: Fenwick, Rockford Auburn, Libertyville, Grant, Lake Zurich

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
BremenHas been a bumpy path in South Suburban
Lake ViewTiebreaker might muddle things but looks like a CPL Blue qualifier

Class 6A North/South Map

Class 7A

Class 7A Enrollment Range: 1833 to 2322

Largest 6A teams by enrollment: Fenwick, Rockford Auburn, Libertyville, Grant, Lake Zurich

Smallest 7A teams by enrollment: Wheaton Warrenville South, Willowbrook, Quincy, Bradley-Bourbonnais, Batavia

Largest 7A teams by enrollment: Glenbard West, Edwardsville, Glenbard East, Downers Grove North, Prospect

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
Wheaton Warrenville SouthToppling Wheaton North helped its stock considerably

Class 8A

Class 8A Enrollment Range: 2351.5 and up

Largest 7A teams by enrollment: Glenbard West, Edwardsville, Glenbard East, Downers Grove North, Prospect

Smallest 8A teams by enrollment: Plainfield North, Maine South, St. Ignatius, Belleville East, Niles West

New teams in field:

Team addedReason for addition
Plainfield NorthWas in 7A
Glenbrook SouthIf 4-win teams do get in, Glenbrook South will likely be at top of that list